Skip to main content

Week 14

1. What is your reaction to the text you just read?

  • It made me very sad, honestly. Emotionally, it was very compelling, but the ending was so bittersweet it left me with a a very sad impression. I'm glad that Yun Ai and Indeling are together, as I did feel like despite Indeling's weird face at the beginning, he was always a good guy. Maybe one day L will come back.

2. What connections did you make with the story? Discuss what elements of the story with which you were able to connect?

  • I really felt badly for Yun Ai and her struggles. Her dad running away, her poverty, her classmates picking on her. While I personally haven't experienced issues this severe, I also was severely depressed at points in my life due to my ongoing depression (I am medicated, don't worry!) and I can understand how she felt. The feeling of losing hope, of giving up on your dream, that is something I've once felt before. But the journey of regaining hope is also one I've gone through.

3. What changes would you make to adapt this story into another medium? What medium would you choose; what changes would you make?

  • I think this would be good as an anime or even video game. I've seen lots of indie j-horror/thriller rpgs that work well with stories like this. For an anime, I don't think too many changes would need to be made. However, for a game, the story would have to be adapted in a more interactive way for sure. There could also be more endings, if it was a video game. Such as one where Yun Ai doesn't help L, or where there is a "bad" end, etc. I think as a video game it would be a really great interactive visual novel/story focused game.

4. In what ways does this story seem more adapted to an online environment?

  • It reaches more people, and also the webtoon format was utilized well in the drafting.

I also got Spicy Tuna Roll.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

PERSONAL MANGA

2 comments
Read more

Week 13

I read some of Oishinbo and I wanted to discuss one of the chapters I found interesting this week, which was the chapter on tea. I didn't find it interesting because of the tea, in fact tea wasn't talked about that much. Rather, I found the concept behind the chapter more interesting. It was the reflection of a Japanese-American senator who came back to Japan to find that all his old friends became wealthy, and seemingly lost their "spirit". I find it ironic, because the mangaka puts America in a good light in the senator reminding both the viewer and the characters of the manga to not consume too much and not to lose their Japanese spirit and heritage, yet America is one of the biggest countries that pushes capitalism and consumerism. So, to me, it's ironic that the Japanese-American senator is sick of the wealthy lavish displays of food from his old Japanese friends. Though, it makes sense given his background that maybe he's also tired of American displa...
1 comment
Read more

Week 2

This week, we read Ayako  by Osamu Tezuka. My personal opinion is that I am not a fan of this manga. While the concept of the story is interesting, I think not only the translation is awkward, but also the pacing of the story. Usually what compels me to become invested or feel attached to fiction are the characters, or worldbuilding--which isn't really applicable for Ayako , but none of the characters are very enjoyable for me, except Naoko and Su'e. Even Ayako herself leaves me unsettled and disturbed at the end. Aside from the characters that make me a little more than disgusted by their nature, the story pacing and translation was also jarring to me. I understand trying to interpret a dialect; however, the way the translator did it made it very awkward to read (at least from the version I read online). In addition, the story pacing does not seem to develop "naturally" to me. Like, at the end when Shiro just whips out TNT and blows them all up... What? Where did...
Post a Comment
Read more